PRELIMINARY REMARK
This is the second of a series of texts that should be
read in the following order:
Movement conjuring signs
Sonorous
beings and absolute music
Auditory
mimesis and music
Whoever is not familiar with the concept of 'mimesis' should
first read
Mimesis'
INTRODUCTION
In the text 'Movement conjuring signs'
we got acquainted with a special kind of auditory signs: auditory movement conjuring signs
for singing, working and dancing, which, next to auditory expressions
(like weeping and laughing) and verbal language, belong to the most
important elements of the human auditory appearance. In the text below,
we want to show how the auditory movement conjuring signs can be
heard as auditory phenomena in their own right. The sounds of movement conjuring signs
for work and dance music, as well as those for auditory
expressions and speaking, are then heard as moving sound, which is experienced as a sonorous
being in musical space. The shift of the attention to what we
could call the sonorous body lies at the roots of the development of
what is called 'absolute music'.
Let us describe this metamorphosis step by step.
THE SONOROUS BODY (1): PITCH
The most important factor that draws the attention to the sonorous body
as such, is the introduction of sounds with discrete and fixed pitch.
Tones seem to escape the laws
of the visual, three-dimensional world: we do not hear the tones of the
harp where the fingers touch the strings. When our fingers glide
back-and- forth over the strings, it is as if the tones go up and down.
Apparently, the tones organise themselves on a vertical axis from high
to low in a musical space of their own. After their ascent in musical space,
they leave the sound source that produced them behind in the
three-dimensional world. In musical space,
they seem no longer to be produced with fingers on an instrument or
through vibrations of the vocal chords: they are experienced as
autonomous auditory appearances - as sounds floating in musical space. In
the real world, the phenomenon does not occur, were it alone for the
fact that most natural sounds are not pure tones, but also because, even
when we are dealing with tones, we always try to locate the sound source
visually - although that is not always obvious, as is demonstrated with
ventriloquism. We only experience a comparable uncoupling when it is
impossible to locate the sound source in the visual word, as with
thunder or echo.
The uncoupling unfolds to a full ascent of musical space when
several discrete tones are heard together or one after another,
especially when overtones become audible - think of the 'quintina' - a
'female voice' that becomes audible when males sing a capella on Sardinia
(Bernard Lortat-Jacob).
The phenomenon is to be heard in all clarity in the 'Hostias'
from the Requiem of Berlioz, when, between the singing of the choir, but
above all at the impressive conclusion, the trombones and the flutes
resound; in Les mains de l'abîme
of Messiaen, when, after a short introduction (1' 35"), three
voices begin to move independently in three layers of musical space; or
in the wonderful 'Stasimo
secondo' from Nono's Prometeo.
THE SONOROUS BODY (2): MOTIF, MELODY, HARMONY AND POLYPHONY
Not only pitch seems to withdraw sound from the real world and to
reallocate it in a musical space in its own right, also the concatenation of
sustained sounds to motifs and melodies has the same effect. As long as
tones are merely isolated events, it is natural to hear them as sounds
that are produced by a musician. In a series of such isolated events, the sound
acquires a certain autonomy when it appears to be part of more
encompassing wholes like measure or metameasure, especially when,
through variations in pitch, it also appears to be part of a more
encompassing tonal structure - a melody or a succession of chords.
But as long as a melody continues to consist of isolated events, we
continue to hear the up-and-down of the tones as a sign for a movement,
and as the products of the playing of a musician on a musical instrument. We described how an ever
broader array of instruments make it possible to produce sustained tones.
When such tones are combined to motifs that conjure movements, or - as
is from the beginning the case with speech music - to melodies on
longer successions of words (verses, stanzas), the attention shifts
from the isolated tones to the succession as a whole. The succession of movement conjuring signs
is then no longer heard as a succession of isolated tones of different pitch, but
as one and the same sound that appears on different heights - as a
melody.
The capacity of the voice or of instruments to produce a continuous succession of
sounds is variable. Unbroken continuity is the rule with
auditory expressions: think of the crying of the baby, the howling of
wolves or the song of whales. With verbal utterances, the continuity
of the expiration is broken through articulation, whereby a whole array of
attacks - the consonants - is joined by a whole array of sustained tones
- vowels. It suffices to omit the consonants when singing (and
that is from the beginning the case with instrumental singing) to obtain
a full melody where the beat and the rhythm are no longer marked by the
onset of an isolated tone, but by pure change of pitch. With the voice and wind instruments,
the length of the succession is limited by the necessity to breathe in
again ('Om).
This problem can be solved through circular breathing; or with
instruments like the bagpipe or the organ.
With bowed string instruments, the length of the 'expiration' can be
prolonged at will - think of the grandiose melodic arc in the
Adagietto of Mahler,
of the melodies in the
Vorspiel to the IIIth
Act of the Tristan of Wagner, or of the long succession of chords
at the end of 'Im Abendrot' of Richard Strauss. Even the nearly
perceptible interruption caused by the change of the direction of bowing can be
got rid of, as with a hurdy-gurdy, or, better still, in an orchestra,
where seamless changes of all kinds can be obtained through gradual or
differential onset - think of
Atmosphères
of Ligeti or the spectralists. With electronic sound production, there are no limitations
whatsoever. Let us remark that also a fast repetition of notes may
give the impression of a continuous movement, so that also plucked or
struck string instruments can proceed to producing sustained tones -
just think of that marvellous
Finale Presto
of the 2nd piano sonata of Chopin.And that reminds us of the fact
that also purely rhythmic formations can be experienced as coherent
entities, especially when they are no longer meant to conjure human
movements, like with Taiko
drummers.
The more a tone comes to unfold in time into a melody that comes to
freely traverse musical space, the more compellingly is it experienced as a sound that moves in musical space. Conversely, it becomes all the
more difficult to find movements of the human body that could be the
earthly analogue of such a melody, or to hear the melody as the (vocal or
instrumental) singing of the singer or the musician that plays it. The
only solution is to no longer conceive of the sound as of a movement
conjuring sign for vocal or instrumental song or for dance movements, but
to hear it as a sound in its own
right that seems to follow its own trajectory in musical space. We will
come back on this subject in 'preferential reading' below.
The reading of tone as a sonorous being imposes itself especially when several
melodies begin to move simultaneously. That begins already when men and
women sing together, so that the voices begin to move in parallel
octaves. But soon the voices begin to move independently, as when one
voice begins to move freely above sustained bass notes, like in
Gospodi, or
the later cantus firmus, whence full polyphony and its monodic
offspring. Other trajectories towards polyphony are conceivable (Aka
polyphony). But in all these cases, tonal relations,
that up to now were only audible as succession, become also audible
as simultaneous distances between the voices: as a succession of chords.
Nothing contributes more to the unfolding of musical space than the
combination of independent voices moving through chords. Chords as
such already exert a magical attraction, but is only in the
succession of chords that the magic comes to its apogee and that the
emancipation of the sound, which was already announced in the single
melody, is fully realised. That magic is all the greater since - as
already Pythagoras discovered - it seems to be governed by
a system of simple mathematical proportions, that are easily discovered
and applied when building musical instruments.
It is through the magic that unfolds when sounds begin to move in musical
space, that the metamorphosis of speech music and dance music into what
is called 'absolute music' is accomplished. A comparison with that other
typically human auditory sign system - human language - is instructive.
The sonorous body of the verbal signs can here equally draw the attention,
but the system of oppositions that structures the verbal sonorous bodies
(the system of vowels and consonants) does not lead to the ascent of a
new world - especially since the consonants belong to the kind of sonorous
material that is common in our everyday auditory environment. That is
why endeavours to create a new world with the sonorous material of
language never give rise to a new world: we continue to hearpoems like those ofHugo
Ball or Kurt Schwitters
as - albeit 'meaningless' -'language'.
THE SONOROUS BODY (3): THE MOVING SOUND AS APPEARANCE
We described how pitch lies at the roots of the unfolding of musical
space, and how successions of sounds of increasing duration come to
inhabit that space simultaneously or successively. When it is the same
sound that changes pitch, the impression arises of a sonorous being that
moves in space, and, since it is not an erratic, aimless movement, but a
movement that is governed by movement conjuring signs (see below), the
being seems animated. The colour of the sound, but foremost the course of
its movement has an outspoken expressive freight: solemn or erratic,
cheerful or depressed, elegant or clumsy.
That is why the moving sound is not only the momentaneous appearance of
an enduring being that can take many other positions in space, but also
of something that inhabits the sound - a being with an enduring
substance or a soul.
(Let us remark that the why of this expressiveness should not further
concern us here any more than the question why a certain curve of the
lips has an certain expression: that is a problem for a theory of
expression, like Darwin's 'Emotions and expressions of man').
The sound that moves in musical space is no longer an accumulation of auditory
signs (for the movement of dancers or the expression of the singer), but
a phenomenon sui generis, and not so much a mere phenomenon, but rather an
appearance in the double sense: a momentaneous phase in the process of
appearing, and the outer appearance of an internal soul. Granted, this
is a most remarkable being. Since only an auditory appearance is given,
we cannot conjure up other appearances in our mind, like we do with the
visual image of singing whales or weeping children. The sonorous
beings in musical space are monosensorial beings. Also in the visual
world, there are monosensorial phenomena (fire, the rainbow, polar light,
mist and sunsets). To avoid misrecognising the monosensorial nature of
sonorous beings in musical space, we will avoid speaking of an
underlying substance, but rather of a soul that inhabits not so much a
tangible body as rather an immaterial sound. Substance is a term that
suits the visible world, where substances are mostly tangible and
material. The term 'soul' is also appropriate because the human voice is
a sound that resounds from behind the visible surface of the body and
that informs us about what is not visible 'inside' the body. Also Schopenhauer's
will is
all too readily associated with movements of the body in a
three-dimensional world. The soul of the sonorous body is rather akin
to the ghost in the marsh fire. Therein, the soul of the otherwise often antropomorphous sonorous beings differs radically from the human soul
that has descended into a material body.
The shift of the attention to the sonorous body has as a consequence
that music is no longer read as an exherent movement conjuring sing that
conjures movements of bodies that are susceptible to gravitation, nor as
inherent movement conjuring signs that conjure the (vocal or
instrumental singing) of bodies of expressive beings, but as the
auditory appearance of a being wherein an autonomous soul manifests
itself .
n
the first instance, it is existing speech music and dance music - foremost
the virtuoso version of 'play
music' - that may be read as absolute music, and absolute music may
to a great extent develop within the confines of speech music and dance
music. But it is obvious that the perspectives opened by the
reading of sounds as moving beings are so promising, that absolute music
will soon break any bonds with vocal or instrumental singing and
with working or dancing bodies, so that the sonorous body can unfold in
all its glory.
As soon as that is the case, music is no longer experienced as the vocal
or instrumental expression of a singer or a musician, nor as a sign for
working or dancing bodies, but as an expressive moving sound.
Let us illustrate this scheme with a progression of examples. In the Vorspiel to
the 3th act of the Tristan of Richard Wagner sounds are moving from
the depths to the highest regions of musical space. In the
overture to Lohengrin
of Wagner sounds descend in ever lower regions of musical space.
In the
Finale Presto
of the 2nd piano sonata of Chopin, a musical being is moving erratically
through broad regions of musical space. In most polyphonic music, par
excellence in the fugue (for instance Bachs Contrapunctus
1), several kindred beings ('voices') are moving in diverse layers
of musical space.
Less anthropomorphic beings appear in
Atmosphères of
Ligeti or Pithoprakta
(1956) of Xenakis, and with the
Taiko
drummers.
The examples are chosen with care, because there are many examples
that are less convincing. The reason is that many absolute music is
combined or condensed with other kinds of music - which adds only to the
protean nature of music, that is already familiar to us from (Proteus)
and which is a major obstacle in a proper approach of the phenomenon of
music.
But, before delving deeper into this, time has come to make a general
statement on the nature of the music that consists of sounds that are no
longer read as movement conjuring signs
ABSOLUTE MUSIC AND MIMESIS
The above scheme clearly shows why music that is no longer conjuring the
singing or the dancing of human bodies, but a sonorous being sui generis
- music that is no longer speech music or dance music - is an
imitation, mimesis. The auditory appearance that unfolds in
musical space is not emanating from a really existing soul, it is
produced by instruments in three-dimensional space. The singer or
the musician are merely the medium bearers of the moving tones. We could
compare with the way in which marble as a medium bearer conjures up the
visual appearance of the David of Michelangelo that normally emanates
from a real body in flesh and blood. The sole difference is that the
David is a visual appearance of a being that is also tangible (and hence
at least bisensorial), so that we can feel the mimetic difference by
touching the marble. With absolute music, we are dealing with a
monosenosial being whose imitation is bisensorial; here, the mimetic
difference is to be found in that we also see musicians and their
instruments, where we should only hear sounds.
Absolute music is not only mimesis, it is also the very paradigm of
completed mimesis:
through having the musician produce the outer appearance, the composer
conjures up the 'soul' of non-existent beings that come to inhabit that
appearance. The whole world of the sonorous beings in their musical space
only exists through the activity of the musicians; they create the
beings that they are imitating through duplicating their auditory
appearance, just like painters conjure up living beings through
duplicating their visual appearance on a canvas. The irony is that
the very absolute music, that has been proclaimed as the absolute -
'abstract' - counterpart of 'mimetic' photography, especially by
painters, is in fact the very paradigm of pure mimesis - completed
mimesis. Not as negation of mimesis, but rather as its completed form is
music the counterpart of photography, which is the very paradigm of
uncompleted mimesis.
And, since we are dealing with sounds that are really audible, and not
with mental representations, absolute music is also
unmediated mimesis - even
when the sounds are situated in a non-existing musical space.
Finally, we have to remind that absolute music is mimesis of
monosensorial beings.
RESISTANCE AGAINST
THE ACCEPTANCE OF AN AUTONOMOUS SONOROUS BODY
The transformation of movement conjuring signs into moving sound can
only occur when we no longer understand sound as something that is
produced by a musician on an instrument, but rather as the auditory
appearance of a monosensorial being in musical space. Several factors
impede such an uncoupling of sound from musical instrument.
Although we naturally make abstraction of the production of the sound
when hearing absolute music, the absence of an explicit theoretical
model that clearly distinguishes between speech music and dance music on
the one hand, and absolute music on the other hand, hinders us from
understanding sound as an animated sonorous being. That is a first
factor that makes us believe that the sounds that we hear in musical
space are the voices of singers or sounds from instruments. This
approach is anchored in language: we cannot help talking about the
'voices' of the fugue, whereas there is nobody singing there, even not
when the fugue is sung.
The reading of the sound as a product of singer of a player is enhanced
in that we use to listen to music with open eyes, so that we actually
see how each sound is produced. It is as if we lose sight of musical
space when concentrating on the studio where it is produced. In the
studio, we no longer hear movements in musical space, but rather see
fingers and hands at work on keyboards, strings, winds and percussion, -
so that we rather see the sounds move from left to right over the
keyboard rather than up and down in musical space.
But also with closed eyes, the unfolding of musical space can be
hindered in that a sound may all too readily betray that it is produced by
a voice or a musical instrument. Foremost the onset is revealing,
especially with percussion and plucked and struck instruments. Also the
new 'ways of playing' are inimical to the unfolding of musical space -
just compare the
prelude to
the third act of La traviata with Grido of
Helmut Lachenmann. With singers, it is the articulation and the
particular timbre of a voice that betray that we are dealing with a
singer and with which (think of Satchmo), especially when we see him and
when he is a lyric or dramatic singer. The joint onset of several
kinds of instruments reduces the recognisability in that the identity
of each attck is lost in the combination.
Timbre and onset can be neutralised through the use of monochrome
ensembles (choir, string quartet, recorder .... and so on). Also the localisability in real space is important; sounds of which it cannot be
assessed where they are produced - were it only for the echo - cannot
but easily ascend in musical space, especially when the musician is nowhere
to be seen, as with many an organist in a church. That is one of the
reasons why many an instrument has an 'echo chamber' in the guise of a
resonance box. Conversely, drawing the attention to the location of the
sound source (polychorality, letting the sound circulate in space) to
the localisation of sound in three-dimensional space (see 'Musical space'.)
A next factor that prevents a sound from ascending in musical space, is
its similarity to existing sounds: it is practically impossible to hear
the sound of a siren or a train whistle, the breathing in Sciarrino's Autoritratto
or the wordless speaking in Harvey's 'Speakings'
as pure sound. In most of these cases, the sound is coupled to a mostly
visually perceptible object - chain saws,
cracking doors and what have you. The avoidance of similarity with
existing sounds is the main reason why, from way back, music shows an
outspoken preference for pure tones that are produced by musical
instruments: the more sustained and fixed the tones, the less they remind
of the more gliding tones of speech, and the purer the sound, the less
it is likely to occur in the real world. In principle, it is also
possible to hear existing sounds as auditory appearances - just think of
the sound of jet engines (Stockhausen), or when we concentrate on the
song of the bird, rather than on the bird that is singing. But the less
pure the sound, the more it is likely to resemble existing sounds, and
the purer it is, the more the sound sources become interchangeable -
just think of the resemblance between a woman's voice and the sound of a
violin or a flute. When there is no tone at all, musical space cannot
unfold. Let us remark that variations in the width of clusters are
perceived as tonal differences (think of Ligeti's Atmospères or the
beginning of Phasma
of Beat Furrer),
and that many complex sounds are combinations of discrete tones.
A last factor that hinders the uncoupling of sound and sound source is,
that with all speech music and dance
music (just like with their imitations, see
'Auditory mimesis and music'), the
music has the be heard as the sound that is produced by the singer or
the musician indeed: otherwise, it would be impossible to understand
vocal or instrumental speech music as the singing of a singer (be it a
real or an imaginary one like Arianna) or as the playing of a musician
(be it a real of an imaginary one like the Leiermann). Since these are
the most popular kinds of music, it is swimming against the tide to
conceive of sound as of an autonomous phenomenon. Add to this that most
absolute music is combined or condensed with other kinds of music, so
that we have to hear the sound now as produced by a voice or an
instrument, and then as an autonomous phenomenon.
MOVING SOUND AND MOVEMENT
CONJURING SIGNS
After having highlighted the existence of (imaginary) sonorous beings,
and having demonstrated which resistances hinder an adequate perception
of these beings, it matters to refine our analysis.
That sounds are heard as the auditory appearance of sonorous beings
in musical space, does not mean that pitches would no longer be read as signs for the course of a movement, and
even less that their movement would not be organised metrically and rhythmically. Quite the contrary:
their tonal and metric-rhythmic relations are heard as movement conjuring signs that are inherent to the movement of
the sonorous appearance - and hence no longer as movement conjuring signs
that are inherent to the singing or exherent to movements of workers or
dancers. Also moving sounds may, just like singing or dancing men,
organise their movement through meter and rhythm and through tonal
tensions, and synchronise them with those of other moving sounds. And,
since they consist of sounds, they can do so by just transforming
their sounding appearance into movement conjuring signs, just like it
was the case with the musicalisation of speech. Thus, an individual sound - a
melody or 'voice' - can move in a certain measure and on a certain
rhythm, and over fixed pitches that are part of a scale, so that they
generate tonal tensions that structure the course of the movement. Thus,
several moving voices ('the 'voices' in a motet or a fuge) may move in
the same measure, and the distance between them in musical space can
equally coincide with tonal intervals that structure the course of their
common movement.
It is only natural that the sonorous beings move on the tones of a scale,
because such are the tones that are produced by the musical instruments
that are used for playing speech music and dance music. But especially in view of the developments of the past
hundred years, we
should point to the fact that the presence of structured tonal and
metric-rhythmic relations is not at all necessary to be able to speak of
music: not all sonorous beings are moving within an ordered meter and on
ordered scales. Sometimes the tonal relations are secondary, as with
purely moving up and down
over the keyboard - think of the already mentioned
Finale Presto
of the 2nd piano sonata of Chopin or on the many 'waves' of Liszt in as
far as they are read absolutely. Further, a melody can be a-metric and/or atonal. And several - metrically or tonally organised -
melodies may move independently without common meter - polymetric,
polyrhytmic or just a-metric - and on distances that contain no tonal
tensions (polytonal or atonal, or in clusters like in
Atmosphères'
of Ligeti). Let us also remind that not only regularity makes us expect
the next event: also complete unpredictability may produce an intense
feeling of expectation.
The domain of sonorous beings merely overlaps the domain of movement conjuring signs,
which in its turn not only contains the world of moving sounds, but also speech music and dance music, where
the movement conjuring signs are either exherent (with dance music and
most work music), or inherent (most work music and all speech music). We
can visualise this state of affairs as follows (whereby pink refers to the
domain of movement conjuring signs and the red letters to the domain of
moving sounds):
|
|
||||
|
movement conjuring signs: |
||||
| exherent | work - and dance music | |||
| inherent |
language, (semi) audible movements |
sonorous beings metric/tonal |
||
| none |
sonorous
beings ametric/atonal |
|||
The domain of the movement conjuring signs (pink) is only partially
coextensive with that
of music as such: it contains speech-, work- and dance music, and that
of absolute music only partially.
It pays to delve somewhat deeper into the relation between absolute
music and meter, rhythm and pitch. With speech music and dance music,
from both the basic parameters of movement conjuring signs, meter is
imperative and tone facultative (think of marching on the pure rhythm of
drums), but they only come to full bloom when tone is added. Work or dance music
with only tonal relations without meter and rhythm is inconceivable.
| tonal | ||||
| metric/rhythmic | metric/rhythmic | |||
With the sonorous beings of absolute music, things are different, because it is no longer movements of human bodies that have to be conjured up, but all the conceivable simultaneous or successive moments of one or more sounds: very fast and very slow movements, gradual change (glissando, crescendo or gradual changes of colour like in Volumina of Ligeti), and even standstill (like in the beginning of Mahler's Mitternachtslied) or movements that are not metrically organised at all (Stasimo secondo from the Prometeo of Luigi Nono, or the unpredictable 'measure' of many contemporary compositions). We have to construct a different spectrum, hence:
|
|
||||
| neutralised tone | tone | (complex of) tones | ||
| metric/rhythmic | metric/rhythmic | a-metric/ neutralised meter | ||
|
|
At the left end of the spectrum, we have
sounds with metrically organised movement and where tone is
neutralised in that there is (practically) no change: think of the sound
blocks in the Sacre of Stravinsky.
We are dealing with sonorous beings that appear intermittently, whereby
the moment of their appearance functions as a synchronising movement
conjuring sign. At the opposite end, we have sounds that are
(practically) not organised metrically or rhythmically, but only
tonally, like in the first stanza of 'Hor che'l ciel'
of Monteverdi,'Institution de l'Eucharistie'
of Messiaen, the end of 'Abendrot' of
Richard Strauss, but above all in
Guai ai gelidi mostri of Luigi Nono.
The less metric-rhythmic the sonorous beings, the more they discern
themselves from the movement conjuring signs of dance music, and the
more easily musical space unfolds; the more metric-rhythmic the sonorous beings,
the more they come to resemble the movement conjuring
signs of dance music - just think of the Sacre, and the greater the
resistance against the ascent of the sounds in musical space.
That is why it comes only fully apparent that there is something like musical space
inhabited with sonorous beings when their movement ceases to be
organised metrically and rhythmically (as in the already mentioned
Guai ai gelidi mostri). But absolute music can stress its
inalienable identity also through movements that can not be executed by
human bodies: think of the scherzos of Beethoven (Scherzo
quartet opus 131) and Brahms, or the studies of Chopin
and Liszt (La leggierezza), or the early works of Xenakis like
Pithoprakta
(1956).
THE COMMUNITY OF THE SONOROUS BEINGS: SYMPATHETIC
MIMESIS (1)
'Singend und tanzend äussert sich der Mensch als Mitglied einer höheren
Gemeinschaft:
er hat das Gehen und Sprechen verlernt und ist auf dem
Wege, tanzend in die Lüfte emporzufliegen'
Nietzsche, Geburt der
Tragödie, (1871).
Rhythmically, metrically and tonally organised movements ignite an
irresistible urge to imitate them. In
'movement conjuring signs',
we already described how that leads to the formation of the community of
speakers (like praying believers or scanning demonstrators), workers or
dancers. In that community, all enjoy the sense of community that
originates in simultaneously executing the same movements, but also
the activity itself, in case: the performance of (subdued or crazy,
erotic or aggressive,....) expressive movements.
Especially the movements in absolute music (in so far as it is
structured by inherent metric and tonal movement conjuring signs) are apt
to ignite the urge to join it. Therein it comes to resemble
the very speech and dance music from which it had emancipated. But,
there is a difference: the movements that are conjured up here, are no
longer movements of the human body (speaking or singing, working or
dancing), but movements of sonorous
beings in musical space. Whereas in speech music
and dance music, movements are conjured up that are made for human
beings, it is not evident to join the movements of sonorous beings - we
can move on the surface of the earth, but not in musical space, and we
have a body that is only able to perform a
limited range of movements. Only when we leave our body in the material
world, in the wake of the sonorous beings that left the musical
instruments to which they owe their existence behind, can we join the
movements of the sonorous beings. In the ideal case, the listener
undergoes a metamorphosis into a sonorous soul that joins the movements of
the sonorous beings in musical space. We can speak of a kind of ascent
in heaven, like Nietzsche in the quotation above.
And, since all the listeners are moving along with the same
moving sounds, they become one with each other and with the moving
sounds in one single encompassing ethereal community
But, whereas all those who sing or dance together can hear or see each
other, and hence enjoy their communal merger with the singing or dancing
community, in the concert hall only immobile listeners are to be seen
who seem to look at the spectacle of an orchestra playing, while in an invisible musical space the souls
of the listeners are moving together with the sounds that are duplicated by
the orchestra. Only after the concert, they express their consent by
applause. The situation resembles that of the readers that read a novel
in seclusion and talk about their experience afterwards.
If there is something like a community of moving
souls, it is to be heard in musical space (the pink cell), whereas the
community of speakers or singers (yellow cell) is audible in the church
or in the streets, and the community of dancers is visible on the dance
floor (grey cell)..
To highlight that
phenomenon, I have given it a name: sympathetic mimesis - the
identification with imitated beings. Whoever listens to Isoldes Liebestod, is
joining the ecstatic movements of the sounds. Therein, absolute music
differs from the normal, non-sympathetic forms of mimesis: whoever sees
the Mona Lisa smiling, does not feel inclined to smile along with her,but rather reacts as it is appropriate to such appearance.
Let us remark that such an imaginary community of listeners and sonorous
beings is not always formed: that is only the case in so far as absolute
music is condensed with inherent movement conjuring signs.
When that is not
the case, the soul of the listeners continues to dwell in their bodies,
like with other forms of mimesis. That is especially the case with music
on the right side of the continuum in the scheme above, where there are
only (the rests of) purely tonal tension: our attitude towards Pitoprakta
does not differ from that towards an avalanche or towards the weeping of
a child - and is similar, hence, to that towards the smile of the Mona Lisa. In 'Auditory mimesis
and music' we will demonstrate that sympathetic mimesis is not a
privilege of absolute music, but that it is a general characteristic of
mimetic music as such: just like we join the ecstatic movements of
sounds in Isoldes Liebestod, we also join the lament of Monteverdi's Arianna.
THE IMPLOSION OF ABSOLUTE MUSIC IN NON-MIMETIC MUSIC
The
presence of movement conjuring signs in the auditory appearance of sonorous beings
carries a danger: they threaten to inspire not so much the
sonorous soul of the listener, as rather his body, that then feels
compelled to dance or play (or sing) along. Both propensities hinder the
advent of musical space and the conception of music as an autonomous
moving sound, whether or not in combination with the factors with the
same effect that we mentioned above.
Let us first examine the propensity to interpret the movement conjuring signs
that are meant to structure the movement of the sonorous beings as
exherent movement conjuring signs for the movement of tangible bodies -
as a kind of dance music, - rather than as an invitation to join the
movement of the immaterial sounds after our own transformation into a
sonorous soul. The temptation is all the more real when absolute music
resembles dance music
(Handel concerto
for harp, Stravinsky's
Symphonies of wind instruments). When the sounds move in a meter
and in a tempo that suits the movements of legs, arms and hands, the
tangible body can no longer refrain from moving along.
But the reverse metamorphosis of sonorous soul to moving body is only
partial: it is only parts of the body that begin to move, and their
movements are only a faint afterglow of the richness of the movements of
the sonorous beings (especially when it is not a single being that is
moving there, but several) if they are not confining themselves
to the performance of some arbitrary movement in a measure that
structures totally different movements of the sonorous beings. It is as
if the ethereal world of the sonorous beings is partly anchored in the
visible, material world. Whereas we are dealing with a double - proper
and improper - interpretation of the music, the false impression arises
that there is only one dimension: as if the sounds that are moving in
musical space would conjure up the movements of the listeners, not
otherwise than the sounds of a dance orchestra.
Far more fertile is the temptation to have the movement conjuring signs
no longer conjure up merely the movements of the moving sounds and
sonorous souls, but also the movements with which it is produced. With
the listener, that leads to the propensity to sing or play along, or to
feel like a conductor that conjures up the playing of the musicians, and
,with the musicians, to the propensity to conceive of the movement of the
sonorous beings as their own vocal or instrumental singing:
Also this double phenomenon is often read
elliptically as if it were a single phenomenon: the listeners and the
musicians get the impression that the music is their auditory
Absolute music is then experienced as if the were the
vocal or instrumental expression of the musicians.
SYMPATHETIC MIMESIS AND EXPRESSION
Such elliptic reading lies at the roots of the ineradicable
misconception that absolute music is the appearance of the musician (or the composer)
rather than of sonorous beings.
The adepts of this theory mostly forget that there is often not only an
immense difference between the nature of the musician and that of the
musical being that is conjured up in musical space - just think of the
difference between the unsightly organist and the overwhelming 'Eglise
éternelle' of Messiaen, but that there are also purely quantitative
differences: either there is only one musician for many musical beings
(as with the execution of a fugue on the piano), or several musicians
are conjuring up a single sonorous being (think of Atmosphères of Ligeti).
Against this background, there is some irony in the expressive
performances of four part fugues by musicians like Glenn Gould.Absolute
music is thus not the expression of the performer, even when it is a
lyric or dramatic singer like in the love duet of Tristan and Isolde
or in the Liebestod: how less we are dealing here with singing beings
becomes apparent as soon as we realise that the singing 'voices' are
embedded in instrumentally played movements, or when we hear
instrumental
versions, or just listen to the Vorspiel. We come back to these
problems in 'Auditory mimesis
and music', where we shall see that the problem with absolute music
is only a particular variant of the problem with imitated auditory beings in
general, and how it is obfuscated by the many kinds of combinations of
many kinds of music - like in the Tristan.
Except when we are dealing with vocal or instrumental speech music (or
with the imitation of singers which will be dealt with in
'Auditory mimesis and music'), music is
something quite different from weeping or expression in general.
The wrong idea that absolute music is the expression
of the composer or the musician, entails a misunderstanding of the
phenomenon of sympathetic mimesis. We have seen how the inherent
movement conjuring signs that conjure up the movements of sonorous
beings may also elicit the propensity of the listener to move along as a
sonorous soul, or, less appropriately, as a singer, musician or
conductor, yes even as a dancer. Whoever understands absolute music as
the expression of the musician, cannot but understand such moving along
as a direct transfer of the emotion of the musician or the composer on
the listener. In reality, we are only dealing with a more complicated
version of what happens when the community of the singers sing together
or when the community of the dancers dances together: the sympathetic
singing or sympathetic dancing that we described in the previous text ('Singing
versus listening').
PROTEUS: DOUBLE AND PREFERENTIAL READING OF MUSIC
Apparently, absolute music is not always heard as absolute music. The
degree to which it is heard as speech music or dance music depends on
the nature of the music itself: to what extent is musical space
unfolded, to what extent is the individuality of the sonorous beings
accentuated (length, gestalt), how many musical beings are there
(polyphony, fugue), in how far do the sounds lend themselves for a
reading as auditory expression and speaking, or as signs for the
movements of human body, and in how far can the sound be uncoupled from
the instrument on which it is produced.
Also the reverse is true:all speech or dance music can be
heard as absolute music, and the more easily when musical space is not
confined within the limits of a single octave, when more than one being is
moving, when sounds resemble less the auditory expression and speaking,
when they lend themselves less to execution through the human body, and
when they can easily be uncoupled form the instruments on which they
are produced.
Thus, the long sustained tones in 'Nacht und Träume' - that do not
particularly resemble articulated speech music, but are nevertheless
taken for expressive speech music because they are sung on words, lend
themselves also, or even better, to a reading as sounds moving in
musical space, all the more since the movement conjuring signs in the
accompaniment facilitate such reading. The same goes for Barbarina's
cavatina
'L'ho he perduta'. And the music of the Vorspiel to the third act of the
Tristan can in the beginning also be read as a kind of auditory expression, but as soon
a reading as sounds ascending to heaven imposes itself irresistibly.
Although every kind of music can be heard as expressive speech music or
as dance music and as absolute music, it is apparent that there is
something like a preferential reading.
The possibility of double reading should not make us blind for the
existence of opposite kinds of music, nor should we feel obliged to
range music exclusively in one of those categories. Only when we
recognise that there is something like preferential reading do we begin
to realise that there also many kinds of combinations.
In the next text, we will show that other kinds of mimetic music only
come to add to the kinds of music that can be read as absolute music and
only increases the number of possible combinations of different kinds of
music.
© Stefan Beyst, spring 2012.